
Today a handy
Lifehacker post introduced me, and apparently everybody else on the internet, to a new multi-protocol IM client called
Digsby. I've been a satisfied
Pidgin user since
upgrading switching to Vista a year ago, which turned out to be incompatible with my old IM client of choice, AIM 5.2 (with the now-defunct
AIMutation installed to remove all of the bloat and add chat window tabs and logging), but I like to be open-minded when it comes to new software options. After playing with it for a day, I'm ready to proclaim it to be full of potential, but not
quite ready to supplant Pidgin as my go-to IM app.
What I like:
* Cleaner looking than Pidgin. Pidgin suffers from that open source look that reminds one of Soviet architecture. Even the skins are a bit crap. Digsby, by comparison, has a much more polished look and includes a variety of (mostly ugly) skins and themes.
* Not having to install three separate applications to make it work. Seriously, I get that Pidgin is a community project, but c'mon - Aspell, GTK+, and at least one other program just to make an IM app work?
* Better email management than Pidgin. I can even compose email to be sent through Gmail within Digsby.
* Facebook integration. Not that I'm a huge Facebook fanatic or anything, but it's nice to not have to load the page to see when people post updates or to change my status message.
* Customization - I can customize how the buddy list displays information to an almost ridiculous degree. For example, if I want buddy icons displayed at all, I can have them to the left or right, and any size I want. If I want a status icon, it can be to the left or right, or it can be a "badge" on the icon. Craziness.
* The ability to drag and drop conversation tabs between windows, or out of a window to create a new window. I can't tell you how many times I've wished Pidgin would do this.
What I don't like:
* Most of this can be filed under unfinished features, like wonky text formatting, no hyperlinking in IMs, can't set your own icons for buddies, etc.
* Eats RAM like it's Firefox or something. Why does an IM client need 75MB of RAM? The developers claim to be working on optimization, though, so this could be a temporary issue.
* Can't change what my name shows up as. I don't care what my screen name is, I want it to show up as "Me." For example, I want the conversation window to look like this:
Me: Hello.
[Insert your name here]: Check out this awesome link!
Me: Die in a fire.
* Can't disable emoticons (without a hack). There's no emoticon to express how much I dislike emoticons.
* Log viewer is on par with Pidgin, but not as good as Trillian's. I want to be able to see all the conversations I had on a given date, dammit, not just one contact at a time. Search also needs to be log-wide, not just the currently selected conversation.
* Nowhere to store buddy notes. I need somewhere to jot down notes on PR contacts, or specify which people I hate, and why. Pidgin has this one.
* Lack of individual alerts. This is something I haven't been able to use since AIM 5.2, but I had all kinds of fun assigning different sign-in sounds to each person. I could who was signing in without even looking at the buddy list.
* Can't specify where I want my chat logs stored.
* Ugly logo. If your logo is a fat kid, you're doing something wrong.
However, if Digsby manages to fix even half of these issues, it stands a good chance of winning my heart/mind.